i had the fortune to see gloria anzaldua lecture once. it was at the queer studies conference in iowa city. she was one of the keynote speakers. she gave a lecture i shared often when i was asked to guest lecture on identity.
anzaldua spoke on identity, of knowing who you are. she used an analogy of thinking of yourself as a tree. your identity as the roots that hold you firmly in place. you must know all these parts of you, and own them, accept them. otherwise, when those mighty cultural winds come, and they will come, you will get blown away.
i go back to this lecture frequently. especially as i change and grow as this culture continues to try and box people in and tell us who we are… it’s a marketing strategy. i especially think about it when i try to sort out identity politics. i’ve never been a fan of identity politics.
do my politics influence my idenity, or does my identity influence my politics?
should they even be connected?
for me knowing who i am and what i stand for is key to simply moving in this world.
but should this be a factor in politics?
i should be voting for someone because they are going to guide our community in a good way. in a way that helps our community be a healthy and thriving community with good roads and schools. that makes sure that we have clean air and clean water. to find ways for all who want shelter to have a safe place to find rest.
is this possible in capitalist culture?
my idenity of being queer, or female, or the color of my skin should never have become a part of our politics, and it saddens me that these are the issues that have become our rallying cries every couple of years.
every couple of years the issues shift and change, distracting us from what could really build stronger healthier communities. they make us fight for our right to exist instead of why we have allowed fracking and other extractive industries that are polluting our groundwater and poisoning all it comes in contact with.
don’t get me wrong, we need to fight these anti-trans bills, anti-abortion, anti-immigration, well anything that is anti-some human beings trying to live. but these issues should never have gotten into the political ring.
so i’ve been thinking about anzaldua’s lecture on identity, trees, and roots.
in a healthy intact forest, those roots of individual trees are tangled in with other roots of other trees, and bushes, and plants, and rocks and mycelium, of micro-organisms. all these roots are forms of communication and interaction. they help other trees they aren’t even near. they can send nourishment when another tree is ailing, or warn them of an incoming threat.
this is community
this is community organizing. those roots don’t care what kind of plant they are sharing information and nourishment with. they simply do it to keep a healthy thriving forest.
maybe this is one reason i feel safer in an intact ecosystem then i do in a city.
it is also why i feel that voting in our current system is a “what’s the point” kind of practice.
voting is another way of assimilation. in fact, if one follows the suffragist movements in this country, it is only after a particular group has assimulated enough that they get to vote. or we let them vote as long as they pay taxes, and stay in line.
a two-party system whose purpose is to keep power concentrated is never going to have a system that will bring about its own demise. it is rigged to ensure there is some small measure of pavlovian treats handed out while they continue to beat us for not playing the game correctly.
what’s more, is that it feels to me that this need to keep narrowing down identities keeps us fighting and diverting OUR personal and collective resources fighting one another so we don’t pay attention to those empowered committing genocide with our votes and tax dollars. it is a political divide and conquer/conquer and divide strategy that has never ended.
i’m not saying don’t vote.
also not saying do vote.
do what you need to do.
but when we have a government calling citizens who are fighting fascists in this country, domestic terrorists, we have a deep-seeded problem that is not going to go away at the ballot box.
this is a battle that is going to have to go deep into our roots, to what connects us to one another, and all other living beings. not as a democren or republicrate, but as a living being in community.
it starts with ourselves, knowing who we are, what nourishes us. what do we, as individuals and collectively need to say no to, in order to say yes to another world?






